We The Corporations? I Don’t Think So.
I felt like I was in suspended animation as I read the Supreme Court decision which, essentially enables a corporate coup d’état of America’s Democracy.
Our country’s Founding Fathers never intended for monarchs or the business establishment to rule our nation. No, the Founders of our country began the Constitution with the words, "We the People of the United States…"
That sentiment was again expressed when President Lincoln in his famous Gettysburg Address said it simply but powerfully, that our government was of the people, by the people and for the people.
Corporations are not people nor are they individual citizens. They are chartered by states to conduct commerce. And while I certainly don’t pretend to be a constitutional scholar, I have been reading a lot about this and thankfully, many brilliant minds do agree with me.
While I have always been a long time believer, defender and supporter of the First Amendment guarantee of the right to free speech, the signers of our Constitution certainly did not intend for that to mean that corporations should be able to spend unlimited amounts of money in order to influence the outcome of our elections. Justice Stevens said it perfectly in his dissent of this recent court decision:
“Corporations are not actually members of [our society]. They cannot vote or run for office. Because they may be managed and controlled by nonresidents, their interests may conflict in fundamental respects with the interests of eligible voters. The financial resources, legal structure, and instrumental orientation of corporations raise legitimate concerns about their role in the electoral process. Our lawmakers have a compelling constitutional basis, if not also a democratic duty, to take measures designed to guard against the potentially deleterious effects of corporate spending in local and national races.”
The conversations regarding what to do are just beginning. Many efforts to undo and modify the damage of this 5-4 ruling will probably take shape. There will be attempts to pass a campaign finance reform bill that has merit and will survive the Supreme Court test. Hopefully, Congress will mobilize and pass legislation that prohibits the political contributions of any company that receives government funds and I hope they will also pass legislation that requires companies to get approval from their shareholders before a corporation can spend money on electoral activity.
And maybe, with deep grassroots popular support, organizations will even push for a constitutional amendment to undue this terrible decision. In our democracy, that is the only opportunity that the framers provided us to change Supreme Court opinions. While amending the constitution will not be a short term fix, it may be necessary if we are to preserve the democratic values that we cherish.
Sadly, we really shouldn’t be surprised by what has happened. During George W. Bush’s presidency, Karl Rove made it clear to all that he was laying the groundwork for the corporate-backed Republican Party to maintain political control for decades to come.
Although President Obama convinced the American public in 2008 that the United States was headed in the wrong direction, we should not take for granted that Rove’s plans would immediately unwind. By laying the ground work over eight years with the political appointments of judges, Rove and his republican allies knew that their efforts would pay off down the line… and with this ruling, they have succeeded.
With so much of concern going on, we can’t savor the success of the last presidential election; we can’t opt to sit on our couches and opt out of important elections that will define the direction of our country for years to come.
As voters, we need to support candidates and policies that will promote health care reform, campaign finance reform, comprehensive financial regulation, and strong environmental legislation. We must not allow special interests and their paid corporate lobbyists to block our efforts.
As we work toward change let’s remember that it will also require patience… all the fights for fairness and equity in our country took a long time. The labor movement, women’s rights and civil rights all required years of organizing, marching, lobbying and campaigning till their voices became the law of the land.
I wish this conservative Supreme Court that supposedly exercises judicial restraint and supports legal precedence had not flip-flopped for the second time in ten years (the first being Bush v. Gore) and become the most activist court in recent history. By reversing well-established election law, their judicial activism has set the stage to possibly erode the very fabric of our country.
But now that this has happened, it’s our turn to send a message to Washington. We must support progressive candidates and turn out to vote for them. We must let both the political and media establishment know that we will not let our democracy get taken from us. As we organize, advocate, legislate, litigate, vote and govern, we must stand up to corporate power and speak truth to the American people so that…we the people and not…we the corporations prevail.







Comments for this Statement
Re: We The Corporations? I Don’t Think So.
The whole impact of this decision has been bothering my mind since it happened. Corporations are ruled by CEO's, which, according to the decision, become the "Board of Trustees" of the United States of America.
Their private, egotistic and self-centered desires would implicitely rule the Nation, or at least try to because "We the People" will not stand for such an outrageous intent to violate the basic principles of democracy, which at the same time define the concept of freedom.
What waves of uncertainty, for society as a whole, would swing the tragic modern version of the XXI century's ideological Titanic?
We, the people, do not want to drown the part-time worker who never gets health benefits. We want all of us to have at least the possibility of knowing that our families will have where to go when times are difficult as they are now.
We say no to material selfishness and yes to universal care and happyness. Is this not what we are supposed to be about?
Thank you.
Re: We The Corporations? I Don’t Think So.
"Sigh" Take heart and dig in for the fight.
Re: We The Corporations? I Don’t Think So.
Again and again, Barbra Streisand puts her career and legacy on the line to take a stand on issues affecting average Americans; thank you Barbra. In this circumstance, it is an issue affecting all Americans and, ultimately, all people of the world. The implications of this Supreme Court decision are staggering and we must ALL make certain our fellow citizens are informed on this topic; and people would be informed if our media outlets gave this stunning decision half of the coverage they have given the Dueling Dimwits of Late Night TV.
Our entire political system is in need of an enema to eliminate the roadblocks to justice like the Electoral College, the filibuster, two party system, and senatorial prostitutes (yes, Chris Dodd, I’m talking ‘bout you and your ilk). Americans need to start caring about what really matters and stop getting all worked up over non-events, like “Kanye West stealing that little girl’s big moment”
Re: We The Corporations? I Don’t Think So.
Amen! As a newly registered voter and high school senior, I am so excited for the opportunity to become part of the election process. Our nation is rapidly changing and the right to vote is something which we simply cannot take for granted...if we want America to grow and prosper, we the people MUST vote and educate ourselves on the issues....
Re: We The Corporations? I Don’t Think So.
Totally agree with you on this. The Supreme Court in essence wrote a new law and a bad one at that. So now we the people must act through our representative to correct this horrible mistake. If we don't act or demand action, we will be making the biggest mistake of all - giving up.
Pam
Re: We The Corporations? I Don’t Think So.
Completely agree with you, I came to this wonderful land, pursuing "the American Dream", obviously I did it while Clinton was in the Office, but we know the history, Bush got the office after and everything changed.... now a Conservative Supreme Court is make "corporations" "the people",...... The other night watching President Obama speech, i thought to myself, why dont we change the name of the speech? instead of "the State of the Union", why they dont call it "the State of the Dreams"?...... lol
I still believe in the American Dream, I still believe in the founders and i still believe in the Constitution, but am I going to live enough to see the American dream to come true??? Clinton left the office with a great economy and wonderful image of America all over the world, its a shame what Bush did during 8 years and now a conservative Supreme Court that one of the members "mocks" the President while he is doing "the State of the Union address...." did you see that Barbra???? You are an American Dream legend...... Your words and life inspired me and they still do ....... God bless you, Renata and America.......LEANDRO
Re: We The Corporations? I Don’t Think So.
Way to go Barb! That's right! We the people of the United States! I completely agree with you.