What is your favourite scene from a Barbra movie?

What is your favourite scene from a Barbra movie?

What is your favourite scene from a Barbra movie? I have a few comedy favourites...

The rollerskate scene from Funny Girl

The scene where she and Lauren Bacall have dinner in the beginning of The Mirror has two faces ("How old were you...?")

The scene in the bathroom in What´s up doc ("What do you think you´re doing?" - "I think I´m taking a bath, aren´t I?")

Replies for this Forum Topic

aww let's see!
the whole "The way he makes me feel" part in Yentl; the fight between Barbra and her on-screen mother in Up the Sandbox; the part in which Katie begs Hubble to stay for dinner.. and oh-so many more Smiling

I think is from What's up doc...she has a conversation on the telephone, at her house, for a job interwiu or something like that...she speaks like crazy...funny like ....just an Smiling amazing monologe. ! I love It. Smiling

I have always been very impressed with the scene from "Mirror has two faces" where she teaches at the university and Larkin comes in to see her lecture. She seems so confident and her outfit is amazing. And I must agree that the scene where Katie begs hubble to stay for dinner is fantastic as well.

The lecture scene is very well written and dynamic. And anything from The way we were is of course iconic.

the woman in the moon scene from a star is born

I agree, Katie asking Hubble to stay for dinner is a terrific scene in the Way We Were ! Barbra shows how much Katie wants him to be there, all the trouble she went through to get the right food with the last of her 'ration stamps' ; she is totally true to the character without sounding over-the-top 'desperate' for Hubble to stay. It's sweet and touching, esp. when Hubble asks 'what kind of pie??' You just can't take your eyes off her as she intently 'makes her case' for him to stay for dinner. She also looks lovely in that shot, very delicate and feminine even if she IS talking at a mile-a-minute pace (ha-ha). Her eyes are softened by the presence of a man she is undoubtedly falling for.
I also love the scene in Funny Girl, when she and Nick are in Baltimore and he admits to being in love with her (after she ate several lobsters, I recall). They fly into each other's arms and behind them is a beautiful sunset. Fanny asks "you're not saying it just to be polite ?" It's honest, a simply wonderful, natural scene.
There are SO many 'Barbra Moments' in film that I adore. In Yentl, when she is 'burning' he father's dinner (obviously, cooking not being her strong-suit) as he tries to teach a student Talmud, and the boy is failing to 'get it', Yentl yells the answer to "Who is strong ?" (from the kitchen) "He who controls his passions", and the house grows silent. After all, a girl is NOT supposed to know Talmud !
I'll get back to you on a few more later on but these stick out in my mind at the moment. Good topic, by the way !
Enjoy the day ...Fran from Trenton

I am always drawn to the "With One More Look At You/Watch Closely Now" scene in "A Star is Born." Who can't relate to wanting so much to see someone who has been lost to them. And B's performance is just incredible.. mastering the lyrics and music yet showing such sadness and vulnerability.
Also I love the "Piece of Sky" ending to "Yentl". Who wouldn't be uplifted by that?

Hmmm, that's a tough one!

I absolutely LOVE the lecture scene in The Mirror as well!. Her character spoke with such intelligence and fluidity that it was easy to listen to her story and the point she was trying to make, furthur more, while being effortlessly humorous. The character is also very much like Barbra herself which makes that scene even better and the movie for that matter. I wish I had a teacher like that!!

I also love the small scene in The Prince of Tides where Lowenstein meets her son and Tom at Central Park to try and watch them play football (she even brought sandwiches!! Hah). At the end of that scene, Lowenstein asks Tom's opinion about what he see's when he looks at her life. Tom tries to lie at first, but when he tells her: "I think youre a very said woman Lowenstein," I just loved that sencerity and the connection that they shared. It was beautiful as well as the subtle turning point in the story where Tom and Lowenstein are starting connect on a deeper more intimate level. Ah, she's just absolutely amazingg...

SOO many more! I'll have to think of them and post more Smiling

I don't think anything will ever surpass your live performance of "My Man" in Funny Girl. I must have seen that movie a thousand times, and I cried every single time. How could I not? That is closely followed by the similar theme in the final scene in a A Star Is Born, another extraordinarily difficult live musical presentation. Although there are exceptional and wonderful dramatic and comedic moments in all of your films (even the less popular), the musical combinations can only by done by the incomparable Streisand.

well i love the romance scenes from " A star is born" genius! so intense and full of passion!
but my favorite monologue is the scene from "Nuts" were she testifys that she is not crazy! thinking of changing the words and using it in my up coming acting class! : )

Isn't it interesting how many different films are mentioned in your responses to this question? Comedies, musicals as well as drama. Just goes to show that Barbra has truly mastered all genres, and to perfection!

I would have to say when she reveals herself to Avigdor at the end of "Yentl". The dialouge between the two before they finally fall together on the floor is just so moving. She ends it with "Because I loved you" I never get tired of that scene. So Beautiful. Second is "My Man" from funny girl.

I really like Up The Sandbox. When many people think of Barbra Streisand in a movie, they think of her skipping across the screen doing silly songs and dances. She's a terrific singer, but even the best singer can't save a terrible song. But many of the songs she sings are great - Yentl, for example. Hello Dolly has the worst songs. They're well-written, but they're too old-fashioned. There was a movie, The Secret Life of Walter Mitty, where an man with an ordinary life has fantasies of his being a celebrity or doing something exciting. Up The Sandbox has a similar premise. She's a bored housewife who has fantasies. In one scene, she goes with terrorists who blow up the Statue of Liberty - unfortunately, her husband is in there and she goes to save him. The statue falls into the sea, killing them both. Fortunately, this was only her fantasy so she didn't really get killed. A little shocking and unpleasant for many of you, but this is by far her gutsiest role. It has a very pretty song played on the closing credits - it sounds like a kalimba (musical instrument) is used to play the melody. It's in instrumental version of If I Close My Eyes, which she sings on one of her albums - I think it's on Back To Broadway.

Oops, gonna have to admit it: I've never seen Up the sandbox. It's still on my to-do-list. Yentl is however unique in so many aspects. I remember how Barbra explained on The Actor's Studio how she designed that dark and yellow lighting throughout directing the film, inspired by Dutch art work.

Highly recommended for those of you who haven't seen it: Barbra's interview on The Actor's Studio is available on DVD. Approximately 2 hours long, yeah Smiling

First of all I must say I like all the romantic scenes in all Barbra´s films I´ve seen.
Then I love several musical scenes from Funny Girl : I´m the Greatest Star, both roller skates scenes, the Swan Lake scene and My Man.
In Yentl I´m always waiting impatiently for the scene where Avigdor comes to visit already married Anshel and Haddas for the first time. When all three finally sit together for tea each from the "men" tries to cover their real feelings but can´t help looking at a different person they should look at and Babra sings the song "Will someone ever look at me that way?" I love the play of their eyes, the angles of the camera and the music accompanying it. And I also like throwing of the pillows in the wedding night scene.
In Prince of Tides I also like the scene with Tom in New York when he buys the some prawns or shrimps and this beautiful music is playing. I like the atmosphere.

I agree. Barbra as a director is a master of letting the "background" music do the talking in her movies, as she did in Prince of Tides.

When you listen to the soundtrack of instrumental pieces from her films you can almost see the scenes played out in front of your eyes. BRILLIANT!

In "The Way We Were" when Katie tells Hubble that shes pregnant its really cute how she told him. Its my favorite part in any of her movies. Smiling Smiling

He visto casi todas las películas de Barbra y de cada una tengo escenas preferidas. De Funny girl cuando hace el número de patin y cuando canta soy la mayor estrella. De what's up doc? cuando se presenta en la farmacia y persigue al pobre Howard, las escenas de la bicicleta y del juez son muy graciosas. De Funny Lady cuando se presenta por primera vez la obra y todo es un desastre. De Nace una estrella las escenas románticas y el final, muy conmovedor. De Yentl, cuando tiene que compartir la cama con Avigdor y cuando le dice que es mujer, obvio el final cantando A piece of sky. Del Espejo tiene dos caras la noche donde supuestamente iban a tener sexo, sus diálogos con su madre y el final feliz. Podría seguir pero no me quiero extender.

I love a lot of the scenes from Barbra's movies, but the one that gets me every time is from the Prince of Tides. Nick Nolte is rocking her in a rocking chair and they are not speaking. I think everyone would want to be rocked by someone they love. I wish that was a still photo I could own.

Prince of Tides has clearly made an unmistakeable impression on most (if not all) of Barbra's fans ...

This is a really tough one to even begin to answer. Yentl is my all-time favorite movie of all; most likely because it was simply pure passion from her. She was amazing in every aspect and I love every second from beginning to end. I've seen it at least a dozen times over the years.

Prince of Tides - Extraordinary. The best performance of Nolte's career in my opinion, which is NO surprise considering he was directed by Barbra; one of the most brilliant directors of our time.

The Way We Were - Fantastic film. I have no one favorite scene. But I adored th way Barbra brushed Redford's hair off of his forehead throughout. That was her idea to do 'something' throughout the movie that would somehow be meaningful at the end. Amazing. It worked!

Funny Girl - The very end with her live rendition of "My Man". Brilliant Barbra at her best. Unmatched performance in my opinion... and will always remain unmatched. Also the line (as close as I remember) "So, that's my problem...I'm a bagel on a plate full of onion rolls!".

"On A Clear Day..." - I love the movie entirely but really adore that her nightie matched the sheets on her bed. With how color sensitive Barbra is; I've always wondered if she requested that be done. It fit the character so well! Wonderful performance from Barbra in this as usual.

"What's Up Doc" - A fantastic comedy. I've actually seen this one the most (second to Yentl). It's a great, light comedy and is sometimes really great after a long day or week of working a lot! If you haven't seen it you must!

"Mirror Has Two Faces" - Brilliant of course. I love the story, the casting and above all Barbra's direction in every aspect, from lighting to exquisitely capturing emotion on film. She truly brings the best work out of every cast member.

*** "UP THE SANDBOX" - Literally, the best film performance Barbra ever gave. Completely ahead of it's time and to this day; a story which remains incredibly relevant. It's a brilliant take on working mothers vs. full-time mothers and supports BOTH which is refreshing and informative. If you ever saw it and didn't quite "get it", I URGE you to get your hands on the DVD and watch Barbra's commentary. You will get it...and I'm sure love the film! She does an amazing job on the commentary!

It's so hard to choose just one favorite movie scene- so i'll choose 3!

Number 1: "Yentl:" I agree the "disclosure" to Avigdor scene. The fear she portrayed on screen revealing her true self to the one she loves was so heart-gut wrenching, and knowing that she must tell the "truth" in order for her own self to evolve but it could of cost her her life.

Number 2: "Yentl:" (this scene is a really big toss up to me for the number one slot)
Yentl in the synagogue squatting down behind the balcony rail- longing and straining to learn. I could feel the desire in her eyes, and the intense pulling of her soul toward something she was not allowed. Looking from the outside in towards her like she was in jail or a cage.But more so from Yentl's perspective: stuck somewhere she couldn't get out of. I am unable to articulate well what I felt when I saw that scene.
My heart literally "hurt" for Yentl. I even had to stop the dvd for a minute and stare at it. Why? It was familiar. I think because I saw myself, I have known that exact same feeling in my life as a child and young girl. Barbra captured a "feeling" that I had for most of my life- in one single movie frame. That's why I love the song 'Where is it written." Everything I had wanted to be, I was told "No," or laughed at, or simply my presence wasn't even acknowledged UNTIL, as a teenager I heard Barbra tell me "YES YOU CAN"(which brings me to number three)

Number 3: "The Woman in the Moon" singing song. When she says "Little Sister, and little brother..keep on pushing, don't believe a word about things you heard about asking.. too much to soon" Especially the part when Barbra pauses, looks at the camera-they zoom in on her eyes, she's defiant and almost angry with righteous indignation-but guess what? She looked RIGHT AT ME!! (I thought as a 15 yr old kid) I sat on the edge of my seat- and she said "Cause THEY can hold back the tide, but they can never hold a woman, I SAID A WOMAN IN THE MOON!" Then she like nods like "that's right- and that's that! and snaps the mic back in the stand.
Barbra had just told Me, Meee! I COULD DO IT!! A woman told me that! (I had no females in my life). Barbra was my big sister in my head. (lol) Her voice and message "broke through" to me, and I will always be thankful. She will never know what she did for me through her art. That's what arts supposed to do when it's done right. Maybe some people didnt need that message- but as a suffering kid- I did. Thanks Barbra, I got the message.

Number 4: "Nuts" The courtroom scene where Claudia has to be quiet and the truth is coming out- the banging on the drinking glass, the raw vulnerability, the pleading in her eyes for them not to go any further because, as we know, the victim or child always blames themselves and fears judgement....but they do, until they "break" her, and it's not a pretty scene.
But it was necessary again, for Claudia's healing.
Barbra's earlier movies were cool, but they don't touch me like the stuff she has had total control over and directed herself.

Yes, I agree, she is a damn good director-I think hollywood felt and probably still is, intimidated by her overwhelming talent back at Oscar time. People dont know how to "feel" around someone like that -it makes them feel "small" because they compare themselves to her- which is absurd because in the first place, most of them are not even playing the same game! She is in a whole other league! It's like, how do you compare yourself with DaVinci or Pavarotti or something? You don't. You just keep your effin mouth shut and learn from them and appreciate the fact that you got to see something that comes along once in a lifetime- and that it happen to come in YOUR lifetime-like a comet flying through the sky that you can't grasp or comprehend the awesomeness of it- so just appreciate it and love it. That's all they (the DaVinci's and the Pavarotti's-the gifted) want from you anyway.

I'll bet when DaVinci was painting the Sistine Chapel he probably had mockers and people putting him down saying who the hell does he think he is trying to be a sculpture, painter, astrologer, and a scientist all at the same time! Well, ain't nobody laughing anymore.

CORRECTION TO MY PREVIOUS POST: I SAID "DaVinci" IN REFERRING TO THE SISTINE CHAPEL- BUT I MEANT "MICHAELANGELO!!" SORRY, BRAIN CELLS FAILED ME FOR A MINUTE THERE.

I like the little section where she is outside of Keeney's and jumps down the stairs while singing "I'm the Greatest Star" in Funny Girl. Just when she is jumping down the stairs outside. I think that is the scene I love the most.Fantastic cinematography!

Love,
Chip

I have other favorite scenes. I like it when she throws up the money when she finds out she will be a Sadie (on the boat) in Funny Girl. I like the musical sequence for "What Did I Have That I Don't Have?" in On a Clear Day. I like the scene wherein he puts her key on the piano in The Way We Were. I like it when she is driving the cattle in For Pete's Sake. I like it when she sings at the piano (with Roddy McDowall looking on) in Funny Lady. I love the scene when she cries and rips the tape out of the recorder in Star is Born.Also like the scene in that where she sees him dead and says "No- No- No - Please don't hurt him." I like the "No Wonder" sequence in Yentl.I love it when she is in that huge purple hat inside the hat shop in Dolly. I like SO many more. but those come to my mind at this very monent. Good question.

Love,
Chip

My favorite scene is from "Prince of Tides" when Nick Nolte (Tom) was holding her in the rocking chair....I just love that scene....and in "The Mirror Has Two Faces" where she is teaching class and she uses a very truthful statement about being in love...where she says it feels.............great" and she is right... Sincerely, Denine

my favorite movie is "whats up doc?" but one of my favorite scenes is in "Yentl" when she's with Avidor and he grabs her shoulders and says "the wedding!" and she shys away and says "why are you always grabbing me?" and then he starts getting embarrassed and defensive and Saying things like "no i'm not" and she says "yes you are"

or when she's singing "tomorrow night" at the tailors shop and she says "the never really look at me People are blind!"
i just love how she says "people are blind"

Nataline

Yes, typical Barbra moments!

Favorite Barbra scenes from her movies. Actually all of them are pretty spectacular, but a few do stick out.

Funny Girl: I'm The Greatest Star, and My Man
On A Clear Day: Love With All The Trimmings (incredible)
The Way We Were: The telephone scene
Funny Lady: (It's Gonna Be A) Great Day
Owl and the Pussycat: Her first scene with George Segal and the hic-cups scene
Up The Sandbox: her mother breaking in the apartment with the huge wire cutters,
Barbra is fabulous
Too many more to mention. Thanks Barbra for all the hours and hours of enjoyment, you are amazing.

I'm The Greatest Star is one of my all-time favourite numbers!
Both the film version and the vocals on Just for the Record.

Funny Lady is also a great film, which doesn't get enough credit these days, in my opinion.

This is such a nice topic, you can always write something new.
I have just finished watching all Barbra films in chronological order – just to see what it will bring. As I finished I realised I can do it again and new revelations will surely come – till I know all the films by heart – which I still don´t.

My list of scenes before watching all the films chronologically :

Funny Girl: I Am the Greatest Star, roller skates, I am a Woman You Are Man, My Man
Hello Dolly: Hello Dolly song and So Long Dearie
The Owl and The Pussycat : the hiccup scene
Up the Sandbox : the statue of Liberty scene
Funny Lady : The Greatest Day
Yentl : first Avigdor´s visit after Anshel´s wedding
The Prince of Tides : when Tom reveals his secret and Susan comforts him

New scenes after watching all the films :

For Peter´s Sake : driving the buffaloes and the meeting the disguised policemen
A Star Is Born : the death scene and the listening to tape scene
Nuts : when Claudia embraces her mother
The Mirror Has Two faces : the man in the window who puts the LP on and the expression on Gregory´s and Rose´s faces when they hear the music Smiling and the dancing Smiling

Of course there should be much more. At the momet these scenes are the most strongly imprinted on my mind.