Village Vanguard Contests Come To An End
SEPTEMBER 14, 2009, 4:02 pm
First of all, we'd like to congratulate Sobelita for her winning video and to Dina, for being crowned the Cutest Pet! We were impressed with all of the entries -- and it was so difficult to pick winners.
Sobelita's Winning Video:
Dina's Photo:

We'd also like to congratulate all of the other winners in the competition.
If you'd like to request a list of all the winners, you can do so by following these links:
Delicious
Digg
Reddit
Newsvine
Facebook
Google
Yahoo
Technorati





Comments for this News article
Re: Village Vanguard Contests Come To An End
Message deleted by moderator.
Way OFF BASE...and Sobelita...Sing Proud ..:)
I would like to end this by saying that I already congratulated the winner of the video contest Sobelita and REMOVED my posts regarding this contest after I actually LISTENED to a prior post by you - Mr. Bobby Wheeler - and thought about a few things.
Now - I am happy that Sobelita cleared up the entry question MANY of us (who submitted Videos) had. As she stated SHE DID POST TWO VIDEOS - I did not make this up. I am TRULY SORRY that I questioned the legitimacy of her entry - however if the shoe was on the other foot - I do believe she would have wondered the same thing.
No - I did not care for her video - she may not have cared for mine - but we are in a FREE country and I have a right to my opinion. Luckily for her - The Contest Promoters Disagreed with Me ...and I am THRILLED that this worked out in her favor.
I was entirely wrong and harsh in my response to her - and thereby CHOSE to remove my prior comments. Now we live in a world where one can not change their mind or re-evaluate their position ?
Mr. Wheeler - I take offense to your attacks on me and oddly enough - as I stated before - your prior post made me re-think my original posts in the 1st place. Kind of hypocritical to preach one thing and not practice it yourself.
Perhaps, as I needed to do - you too need to Check Yourself At The Door - before you go on a tirade against me saying: " and unlike the sore loser who posted and then deleted his posts ...Funny how some people saying they are "taking the high road to higher ground", and then come back with, "I told ya so's",and cliché nail jokes. Just childish. If there had been a contest for the most use of Barbra Streisand titles in one post maybe this griper would have won.."
It is true that there were coincidences in these contests and questionable issues - THEY HAVE BEEN DEALT WITH and I have moved on...hence my recent posts.
The only thing I will and have apologized for is my treatment towards Sobelita - it was childish, unnecessary, and perhaps I was acting a bit the 'sore loser" .
For this... I SINCERELY APOLOGIZE TO HER !!!!
Every Streisand Fan I have ever met has been, if nothing else, PASSIONATE. Perhaps at times - to a fault. I suspect that is because most of us regard Barbra Streisand with great esteem.
As I stated previously - I only wish the winners The Best.
To Sobelita - I am truly sorry I tried to "Rain On Your Parade"...Please continue to 'Sing Proud"...
- David
Re: Village Vanguard Contests Come To An End
Congratulations Sobelita,
I saw your video, and unlike the sore loser who posted and then deleted his posts, I found your video to be a funny, loving, heartfelt homage to all the exaggerations and " flairs" that we fell in love so many years ago. Great Video and I enjoyed. You could have lost the doll, and had someone film you on the Staten Island ferry, lol. Other than that, terrific!
Am I jealous your going, hell yea, but also happy for you. Your video and effort was deserving, and I'm glad the powers that be had the right sense of humor.
Funny how some people saying they are "taking the high road to higher ground", and then come back with, "I told ya so's",and cliche nail jokes. Just childish. If there had been a contest for the most use of Barbra Streisand titles in one post maybe this griper would have won.
You enjoy the night, and please come back and post of your experience. It is a once in a lifetime treat, you will remember forever. Congratulations again.
To Ms. Streisand. You stole our hearts a long time ago, and continue to do so triumphantly, with this new release. Thanks for all the treats we have been receiving, and to your crew here at the web site for their hard work. Looking forward to the streaming videocast.
Barbra in New York City at the Vanguard. It's so nice to have you back where you belong. Welcome home. Stay a while and feel the love. Congratulations on your latest triumph!
Sobelita Speaks
Ooh life is juicy,
juicy and you see,
I gotta have my bite sir ...
Thank you for enabling me to feel closer to Barbra than I ever imagined I could. Empowered by her song, I placed myself before the camera and embraced all that is Barbra. The result - a winning video. Amidst the lovely support there were cruel insults, unfounded accusations and absurd assumptions. I only wish to make one thing clear: I did not post two videos. I posted the same video twice as I desperately tried to ensure my entry made it into the realm of cyberspace. The judges were kind enough to remove the duplicate. Barbs from Barbra fans are memories - and what's too painful to remember we simply choose to forget.
Love is the Answer.
Going to HIGHER GROUND......
Well, I've had a heavy heart for the past few days and been in a very negative place over the results of these contests -
But I have decided to LET IT GO !!!
1st - I deleted all of my posts regarding this topic here on Barbra's Website.
2nd - Do I feel like there are unanswered questions about these contests? Yes.
But - What if I am wrong in my “assumptions” ?.
I would hate to think that I was harsh and cruel to the lady who won the Video Contest (even though – yes – she posted two videos which violated the rules) because she did legitimately appear to be a Streisand Fan.
Sometimes it’s better to ‘check yourself at the door ' and take the higher road…so in this case I’m going to go to... Higher Ground…
I CAN'T wait for all the wonderful promotion coming our way - I mean an OPRAH and Jonathan Ross appearance and The Village Vanguard Show !!!!!
Barbra Streisand has always remained a TRUE TALENT and if I have learned anything from being her fan - it is... that it is better to Take The High Road then to let things fester and get out of control....
She has been 'stung" so MANY times in her career - and has paved an incredible path for women in entertainment - so like Barbra -
I am going to let "Love" be my "Answer".....
Here's to her New Album ... and Here's To Life..... and Here's to Barbra....
May all of the winners have the time of their Lives in NY .....
Barbra will be SENSATIONAL !!!!!!
- David
Explains a lot
Wow. This explains a lot. This explains why when my friends and family went to vote for my picture, the site was conveniently buggy, and they couldn't get their votes in. The website also said that at one point that the contest was over, though the day had not been reached yet.
Is it true that the dog that won has the same breeder as the dog that Barbra owns? I saw that in this post. That's a bit odd if it's true.
I didn't agree with the rules of this contest in that the amount of votes would get you to win a chance with the judge. I think it should have been judges all along, basing their decisions on the quality of the picture, the cuteness, and more. Not everyone has 100's of people to vote on Facebook. Some people aren't on facebook, and don't even own their own computers.
Some of the comments here, if true, give me pause. If people have sour grapes, it's because they feel they've been duped and they wanted to see Barbra in concert THAT badly.
I know that I would have LOVED to see Barbra, but it was like throwing poop against the tide if I thought I was going to win. I didn't have loads of friends on facebook to vote. Just a few friends and family. I think the contest gave me a false hope, a kind of tease, that I could possibly go see Barbra in concert. Oh well. Streaming the concert from the venue is okay, I guess.
Re: Village Vanguard Contests Come To An End
VANGUARD CONTESTS COME TO AN END: A HIJACKING
=============================================
Dina's breeder = Marilyn Smart
Sammie's Breeder = Marilyn Smart
Contest Winner = Marilyn Smart
Sony = NOT SO SMART
Re: Village Vanguard Contests Come To An End
I don't know who this David is, but it is a shame that he has chosen Ms. Streisands web site to vent his anger.
For many years people have made accusations and complaints that Ms. Streisand didn't respect or appreciate her fans. She kept her distance. Well if this David is the type of fan she has encountered, on her journey to stardom, it is no wonder that she kept her distance.
I am always amazed at fans that "take ownership" of their Idols. It's actually a little frightening. I have been a fan of Ms Streisand for near 50 years now. I pay for cd's, I pay to see her films, I have paid 3 times for the honor of hearing her sing live. She has never disappointed me, she has always delivered exactly what I have paid for. I have no right to expect, nor demand anything more.
Ms. Streisand graciously offered so much to her fans with this upcoming new release. A chance to see her live, multiple interviews, streaming video of the Vanguard performance. Yet some still want more. How long before our beloved star retreats once again to her fortress in Malibu?
Give the Diva a break. Afford her the respect and honor she is due. She has entertained us for near 50 years. She is still young enough, beautiful enough and at the top of her game, to entertain us for many years to come. Be grateful for that. Be grateful for the gift she has shared.
To all the winners, much congratulations. It will be a night to remember forever.
Thank you Ms. Streisand. God Bless you, and may your fans always continue to support, respect and honor you as you deserve.
Re: Village Vanguard Contests Come To An End
C’mon folks…this is getting even uglier by the moment. It’s all so simple, yet those associated either with Sony or personal friends of the contest winners, are trying to make it complicated. Fingers on the part of the contestantees are being pointed for a legitimate reason.
Even Sony’s own rules with respect to the Pet Contest, state, upon entering your photo (“Submission Materials”), you agree that:
(D) the Submission Materials, or any part thereof, have not been commercially released;
The legal definition of commercial property is any property used directly, or indirectly, in connection with any business, or other undertaking intended for profit.
The photo of Dina, although she is absolutely and unquestionably adorable, was listed on the breeder’s website, and the photo HAS been used directly, or indirectly, in connection with their business, such business of which is intended for profit. The photo HAS been commercially released.
Please...stop all the insinuations of “sour grapes,” and “poor losers,” and stick to the facts.
Sony…just come forward, and at least say, “Oops.” That doesn’t take away from how charming Dina is, and it will make a lot of people who put their hearts and souls into this endeavor feel a lot better about the way things were handled.
I’m sure even Dina would agree…"throw" the voting public and the owners of the Top 20 photos a “bone.”
Re: Village Vanguard Contests Come To An End
Re: Village Vanguard Contests Come To An End
Seems like David's wrath goes beyond just not liking the winning video. His comment is filled with rage, frustration and a sense of being horribly wronged. Yes David it is just your OPINION yet you go on and on about truly awful you feel the winning video is. Before you and the other 'critics' spew on and on, remember that there are laws against character assasination and unfounded accusations. There was a sucessful case recently in NYC where an internet fiend such as yourself was speaking out against an innocent fashion model and that person was exposed. You can criticize all you want but unless you have a great attorney on staff I'd tread lighter. I am an attorney so I have a little knowledge on this subject. Obviously both you & Justin are fans of Barbra's but do not speak about what Barbra would do as if you personally know her so well. You don't. This was a contest judged by professional people at Sony who know what elements they were looking for and obviously knew what they liked when they saw it. It is true that there were many fine videos submitted but only one can win. Accept it graciously and move on. Or wallow in your anger if you wish. Barbra's new CD declares that "Love Is The Answer," not Hate.
Re: Village Vanguard Contests Come To An End
Re: Village Vanguard Contests Come To An End
Don't tell her not to sing
She's simply got to.
If someone takes a spill
It's her and not you.
Don't bring around a cloud to rain on her parade!
(Hey Sobelita! I totally get your video. You DO look like early Barbra alot and your 'interpretation' (as the rules stated) was dead-on with passion and unrestrained intensity. Don't let these "I'm-not-a-sore-loser-BUT..." types pull a Kanye West on you. He was wrong and so are these people. Go ahead and beat your "da-rum!" So funny!)
Re: Village Vanguard Contests Come To An End
Before I even go on I just want to say that I do not have any "sour grapes", or that I am jealous that I did not win any of the contests. You win some, you loose some so it's nothing to get your panties in a knot about. And I firmly believe that when one door closes another one opens...and mine already did (thanks again Valencia).....
But I want to say some things regarding the video winner. This video is creative and original which are two parts of the juding criteria that was mentioned on the websites rules and terms. The other two parts that all videos were judged on were vocals and looks (each category being 25%) -- does Sony really think this person has great vocals? Now we all know Barbra's voice cannot be re-produced (that's why I didn't even try) but I mean let's get serious, this video was very hard to listen to - and I have to agree with someone else who said it - but it's kind of an insult to our Barbra, no matter how funny their intentions were when it was filmed. And I am not even going to touch on the looks category, another major insult...
And not to go on, but obviously the rules didn't make a difference in this contest, because this person submitted two video's (under different accounts by the way), and the video that won was her second entry. These fake rules also stated that if ther same person sent in two videos that the second entry would be disqualified and the first one would be the one judged. So Sony, what happened in this case? Again these "rules" didn't make a difference so why even have them? (also it doesn't hurt that this person lives in New York, I guess Sony saved some money on hotel and airfare)
I don't blame Barbra for this at all!! She probably has no clue what is going on, if she did I can be sure this person would not have won.
All in all, congrats to all the winners, you all have gotten the chance of a lifetime to see Barbra live (whether some people think you deserve it or not). Enjoy every moment of it...there are millions of people that would cut their left arm off to just step one foot into that club to hear one note come of those amazing vocal chords.
Love,
Gina
Re: Village Vanguard Contests Come To An End
Congratulations to the winners! What a cute photo. And rotten raspberries to the losers...that would be anyone who complains the contest is "rigged" or "unfair". There were at least five ways to win a ticket to the Vanguard for this culturally historic occasion. Some involved skill (the pixel puzzle), some involved the luck of the draw and one involved the very subjective selection of a cute pet photo. I think the photo of my pet was cute, too. Killer cute. But someone else --perhaps someone very important!-- thought differently.
That's how it goes. In the meantime I bough the deluxe CD and am looing forward to watching the concert right here on my computer, in my lap, with a glass of nice wine and my gorgeous and very cute Dalmatian by my side.
Brava, Barbra and crew. Great marketing...great energy...and everyone who watches whether in person or on their computer will have a wonderful memory. I'm really looking forward to it.
Re: Village Vanguard Contests Come To An End
Congratulations to the winners! Thanks for the opportunity Barbra. My friends and I had a great time entering my kitty, and looking at the other pets. The videos were hilarious. Great choice for the winner. What's with these bitter people who are accusing you of these nasty things? Incroyable!!!! (you understand French). I've already met you twice over the years (lucky, lucky me!!!), so I'm not heart-broken. Anyway, like your clock, I'm counting down the hours, minutes and seconds until I receive my pre-ordered CD's; then look out Long Beach, California; I'm turning it up FULL VOLUME. You are fantastic, passionate, beautiful, with a delicious voice. No one comes close. Thank you , again!!!!
Re: Village Vanguard Contests Come To An End
I can't believe all of the ridiculous, childish criticism posted about the winners of this contest. My G-d, it's just a contest, it's not the end of the world. I don't think anyone's intention was to mislead anyone. I'm sure the winners won justly according to the rules. Why do the people who didn't win have to be so negative. Just sit back, pop in a CD (preferably you know who) and relax. And, don't forget to nosh on a mallomar.
Re: Village Vanguard Contests Come To An End
Again, happy for the winners but sorry the contest was such a scam. I don't think anyone is a sore loser they just wanted a fair contest. As far as the more important things in life to complain about, you may be right but, I wouldn't want my children to think I didn't stand up for something I believed in no matter how small it was. You have taught us all a great lesson Sony! Barbra, we still think your great, but we have really been let down.
Re: Village Vanguard Contests Come To An End
It's not about winning or losing, it's how you play the game.
It is not only right, it is our OBLIGATION, to speak out whenever there is unfairness and deceit.
What many of you who were not involved in the various contests don't understand is that we are NOT upset that we did not win, we are upset at being..."misled," to put it midly.
In the pet contest, Sony/Erlichman/BS, in every communication, put a great deal of emphasis on the importance of accumulating votes. Indeed the "Official Votes" sat that the Top 20 would advance ti the "Grand Finals," thereby increasing an entrant's chance of winning from 1/1,200 to 1/20.
In the end, not only was a pet chosen from outsie the Top 20, but the winner, Dina is:
- the same rare breed, Coton de Tulear as BJS's dog, Sammie
- the photo of Dina was taken by a professional photographer
- the photo was taken when Dina was 16 weeks old...sometime in late 2008
- the breeder of Dina is quite possibly Sammie's breeder
For those of you not involved in the contest, it is easy for you to point a finger at us and say "sore loser." and move on. We are not sore losers; we are fair players.
Do you know what it took to place 1 through 20 among 1,200 plus entries? A LOT OF HARD WORK only to learn that Dina, as described above, won -- without even knowing if she received one vote? For she WAS NOT in the Top 20.
Sony/Erlichman/Streisand APPOINTED a winner instead of letting the votes count.
These entities miscalculated our dedication to Barbra, but most importantly, to our pets. We were deceived and misled and none of the aforementioned are off the hook.
Nothin' like a Brooklyn sucker punch!
Re: Village Vanguard Contests Come To An End
First I like to say CONGRADS!!! to the winners, I hope you have a great time at the concert Second, I can't believe the postings I see on this site; I have been a devoted fan of Ms Streisand since 1968 and though I have never had the chance of seeing her in person and yes I entered the contest; I am not about to throw stones at the people that won, or Sony records or most importantly Ms Streisand. There are so many other things going on in this world; for instance The WAR our men & women are fighting , our Economy,Women & Children being abused, People in this country being killed without reason , and being put down, beaten or killed for being Black,White, Latino, Asian or Gay/Lesbian and some of you with your comments are more concerned with a loved one not getting tickets because they feel someone cheated, without proof of it and others angry because a picture of a dog wasn't in the top 20? If you would take all that wasted energy and pointed towards your Politicians , speak out and let them know how you feel about the War, Healthcare, and abuse and gun control WOW! what impact you would have and changes could start coming about, good changes, or get involved in your community or volunteer, make a difference. Stop! bashing people who have won and are going to see someone they respect and love very much, just like the rest of us that didn't win. Lastly, am I disappointed? Yes but, I won't die from not seeing her and I still have the up most respect and love for Babs. That's all I have to say and I am sure there will be comments but, let it go..Please. Have a great time again to the winners and Barbra knock 'em off their feet!
Re: Village Vanguard Contests Come To An End
Bravo Sobelita!!!!! Imaginative, Funny, and what sets and costumes. Great passion for Barbra and great original rendition of Don't Rain on my Parade, one of my favorites.
Loved it!!!!!!
Re: Village Vanguard Contests Come To An End
THE WINNER OF THE VIDEO " DON'T RAIN ON MY PARDE " IS EXCELLENT
CONGRATULATION FOR THE HARD WORK...BEST REGARDS ( JC ) MIAMI
Re: Village Vanguard Contests Come To An End
Wow! That winning video is painful to listen to. But, maybe it's supposed to be.?
Best, Andy P.
Re: Village Vanguard Contests Come To An End
Re: Village Vanguard Contests Come To An End
Dear HadEnough,
Your command of the English language does not impress me nor does it intimidate me. It merely bores me. I would climb out of an elevator roof and up the cable before being trapped with you and your pompous know-it-all attitude. Get over yourself and your preposterous accusations. The only people reading your manifestos are you and the few fans who made videos. My advice to you is to get out in this world and away from your computer. Develop social skills. Don't slam a young girl from Brooklyn who happened to win without pre-ordering a CD. Your so-called apologetic comment does not mask your insincerity. And yes, I suspect you are a male. No woman in her right mind would harp on this as persistently as you have. I would know.
Anschel
Re: Village Vanguard Contests Come To An End
Wow, Anschel!
I see you amended your original post, after calling me, of all things, a “jealous screaming Queen,” and making statements that I am merely a sore loser. Quite comical, to say the least.
First of all, I DID NOT enter the pet or video contest whatsoever, so your alleged original assumption doesn’t come into play. If you’re interested, however, I played the Pixel Game several times, and pre-ordered the deluxe CDs for myself and a friend. “Notwithstanding the foregoing,” you are both misguided and ill-informed.
Second, presented were the facts. The pet winner was NOT in the Top 20, disenfranchising all of the hard work that those 20 pet owners went through to even get a 1 in 20 shot at the Holy Grail. The winning video entrant posted an earlier one, and the rules are the rules are the rules. That ends the conspiracy theory.
Lastly, even Barbra might think you are a bit over-zealous in assuming I’m a male, with your reference to “his” character. Does having somewhat of a command over the English language preclude that I might be a female? Where is it written? That is quite a contention on your part. How do you figure that I’m a guy? Mmm…that might start another supposed “conspiracy,” as to information you may or may not be privy to, so instead, I’ll let that go, by merely saying:
Regardless of the improprieties, congratulations to Dina & Sobelita, the judges final picks...and thank you for sharing your own unbiased opinions, YENTL.
Re: Village Vanguard Contests Come To An End
Congrats to the winners Dina & Sobelita! Both your cute pet picture and your funny video are deserving winners. Don't let the petty rantings of a jealous person like HadEnough and his ridiculous conspiracy theories affect your shining moment in the winner's spotlight. How one handles victory is important but how one handles defeat says even more about his character. Go ahead ... Keep screaming HadEnough ...just do it from behind the red velvet ropes.
Re: Village Vanguard Contests Come To An End
Congratulations to the winner of the Cutest Pet contest. The puppy is adorable, the photo is exceptional! Unfortunately, the outcome left the leading participants in the contest feeling quite the "fool" for having believed that their hard work and their friend's time voting for their pet was for naught! My pet was close to the coveted Top 20. It took an incredible amount of time and energy to get there. It isn't about being a sore loser. It's about the appearance of impropriety. The rules I saw always allowed someone out of the Top 20 to be chosen. But the emphasis in all communication implied that the number of votes a pet received was critical. In the end, the entire process was just regrettable.
Re: Village Vanguard Contests Come To An End
Unbelievable!
Dina is a Coton de Tulear, an exceptionally RARE breed of dog, like Sammie, and wasn't even in the Top 20....
Sobelita submitted a video earlier under her real name, Jocelyn Gombac, defying all the rules that only the FIRST video submitted can be judged, and those that follow are disqualified, and then the earlier video was conveniently deleted....
and the Streisand-buying public can all just go directly to Hades, because Sony and its affliliates can do WHATEVER THEY WANT, despite the indecent, immoral, dishonorable, unfair, and quite possibly, illegal manner in which this entire process has been brought to fruition.
If Goddard Lieberson were still alive today, this would NOT have happened.
You once said, Barbra, that "the audience cannot be lied to." Quite sadly, you may need to amend that statement after all these years.